How we almost got hooked…line and sinker… by Publish America

#PublishingFoul Logo Indies UnlimitedGuest Post
by Jacqueline Hopkins

Back in 2010, I was living in Alaska, and editing my niece’s book. Shana Gentry told me she had a publisher and they were waiting for her to finish it. I asked her who it was. Proudly, she said, “Why it’s Publish America, of course.” I had never heard of them. Back when I’d tried to get my novel published, I’d gone the traditional route – and Publish America wasn’t one of them. After all the rejections I received, I got discouraged and quit writing, shelving over a dozen books I had started.

In any case, I asked Shana about PA and she said she’d found them online and had already signed a contract with them. When she first contacted them, their response and interest in her book was immediate and very over the top, telling her she had a bestseller and that they would make her a famous author. PA was very prompt in their responses; however, their contract spoke of many charges to come out of her pocket. In fact, she wouldn’t see a profit from sales until they recouped their costs. Only then would get any royalties. Shana also told me she was to pay them around $200 for startup fees and contact placement in the company, and for a front cover and back panel of the book. They also told her an editor would call her and keep in touch with her as she wrote, and that she didn’t need to seek the copyrights as they handled that as well. She told me she had her doubts right away and stopped correspondence with them after about two weeks of back and forth emails and harassing phones calls, pushing her to send the manuscript.

I knew publishers, if they were legitimate, would have upfront costs in editing, book cover art, marketing, etc., so that seemed right. What didn’t seem right were the charges she talked about having to pay to them. Where would their upfront costs come into play if Shana had to pay them for those services?

Of course I got curious about this company and wanted to see what they were all about. I pulled out a contemporary romance I’d written and reworked it. I emailed them right away, sending them a book of over 85,000 words. Their response was incredulously immediate — like the very next morning – saying they wanted my book. My first thought was how the hell does someone read a book that large that quickly? They’d have to be speed readers.

They wanted my book, too and were sending me a contract to sign with a $1 advance. The contract would be good for seven years. Before thinking of even signing it, I did some research. First, I contacted a traditionally published author friend in Hawaii, telling her PA wanted my book. She knew instantly about this company, and she and the other members of the RWA Aloha Chapter said don’t do it. They all advised me to search PA out on the Internet as there had been a lot of complaints about them. So, that’s what I did next. And boy did I have my reading cut out for me on this well-known vanity publisher. Back in the 1980s, the only vanity publisher I knew of was called Vantage and I’d almost published with them, but didn’t have the money then, either.

After my research, I told Shana to get out of the contract with them. She wasn’t sure how to do it. I told her since she hadn’t finished the book yet, to just tell them she couldn’t finish it right now: too many things going on in her life and she couldn’t know when it would be finished. That seemed to do the trick; they released her from it before she had paid them a dime. I’m glad she and I didn’t end up paying any money to them. I had told her that if a publisher wanted her work, they would pay her; that money flowed from the publisher to the author, not the other way around.

As the commercial implies…Stay thirsty my friends… stay thirsty for truth and knowledge in your writing careers, it will pay better in the long run. And If it’s too good to be true, it usually is.

In my opinion, it always pays to ask someone in the industry for their advice. It’s great to be an indie in a culture where others are ready to help. Much success to everyone!


Jacqueline HopkinsJacqueline Hopkins-Walton is the author of Wilderness Heart, selected as a recommended read on USA Today’s Happy Ever Blog. She has contributed to the anthology Twist of Fate, where all proceeds go to help victims of the May 2013 Oklahoma tornadoes, and twice winner of the Indies Unlimited Flash Fiction Challenges. Learn more at her Amazon author page.

Author: Administrators

All Indies Unlimited staff members, including the admins, are volunteers who work for free. If you enjoy what you read here - all for free - please share with your friends, like us on Facebook and Twitter, and if you don't know how to thank us for all this great, free content - feel free to make a donation! Thanks for being here.

14 thoughts on “How we almost got hooked…line and sinker… by Publish America”

    1. What helped me the most probably was the fact I was a member of RWA way back in the mid-1980s and when I went to Hawaii and I started the group there, I got to know a lot of people who were traditional publishers, most still are, so I had the knowledge of what should have happen, like money flowing to author, not away from it. And I was glad I still had those connections.

      Thanks for responding Yvonne.

  1. You were very smart to check PA out before doing any business with them and I’m glad your niece had no problems getting out of her contract. You are one of the lucky ones having a friend to steer you clear of the scammy publisher. Kudos to you, Jacque!

    1. Thank you Lynne. I did a lot of reading about that company…couldn’t believe all the information that is out there for free that other new authors, if they just do their due diligence first, wouldn’t get scammed by them and the other vanity publishers.

  2. You done did good. So smart. I give you credit and admire you for helping your friend and helping other’s by sharing what you know. Wonderful.

  3. Thank you Brenda. You did a great job in telling your stories and I hope we helped some new authors to steer clear of these vanity publishers. Good luck with your situation and much success to you in your writing.

Comments are closed.